Darkholm of Turia, Kinsman, Warrior, and Friend passed on April 17, 1999 to the cities of dust. He was a Man among Men, and we are proud to have known him. We are reprinting his last article here, in a tribute to him. Darkholm you will never be forgotten. May you rest in peace
scarlet.gif - 33105 Bytes
STUDIES IN SCARLET #3
by Darkholm & _Marcus of Ar_

A LINE IN THE SKY

The trackless, ominous face of the Voltai range stretches, in all its stark magnificence, down the length of the continent, like some giant ripple in the fabric of Gor itself. In the north, one can hardly gaze upon its peaks without thinking of the greatest aerial battle in the recorded history of the planet.

The year is 10,010 CA, and thousands of tarnsmen, astride fierce, shrieking birds of prey, are about to lock themselves in a titanic struggle of man and beast, with the Home Stone of an entire city hanging in the balance. A storm had descended upon the scarlet peaks of the Voltai. The city of Ar had come for Treve, and Treve was waiting for them. A line had been drawn in the sky.

But why was the tarn cavalry of Gor’s greatest city winging its way towards the small, fortress-like city of Treve on a mission of total destruction?

The Setting: Treve had long been known as a bandit city. Indeed, she had no other way to survive except through plunder. She had no trade routes, and no exportable goods. Her geographic location made it impossible for her to even grow her own food . If she were to have anything, she would have to take it. If she were to survive, it was to be through force. Thus she worked at honing the quality of the one thing she had in abundance --her tarnsmen-- perfecting the airborne hit-and-run tactics used to execute the raids that would supply her citizens.

At first Treve’s tarnsmen probably stayed well clear of the larger cities, who would have greater resources, better defenses and better training among the ranks of their defenders. This would not last long, however, as such cities would have larger fields and greater spoils.

Eventually their airborne umbrella of operations spread to encompass the valley of the Olni, the banks of the Vosk and every city, settlement and village in those lands. Tarnsmen of Treve struck at the larger cities, enmasse, cities such as Lara, Vonda, as far north as Tharna, as far west as Ko-ro-ba.

Undoubtedly, Ar had kept a wary eye on the increasingly daring raiders of Treve for a long time. She had watched the raiding tarnsmen grow in number with each passing year. Their reputation for cunning and ferocity became more renown, as more and more cities, towns, and caravans of the region became hapless prey. To be sure, the very mention of Treve was enough to send chills up the spine of many an administrator or ubar. With each strike, with each acquisition of plunder, the city became more opulent, her warriors bolder, their thirst for glory more acute. Ar, of course, could not have failed to notice all these things.

It was only a matter of time before the bolder of their tarnsmen began to fly south of the Vosk in search of new lands to raid. Perhaps the High Council of Treve warned against such action, knowing they risked awaking the sleeping giant of Ar; who can say? But Trevan tarnsmen are not known for their adherence to caution. They seek glory, and Ar was the richest jewel in Northern Gor, ready to be plundered.

Eventually, and inevitably, the men of Treve turned their attention to the territories of Ar, striking at outlying settlements, adjoining municipalities, and harrying caravan travel along the Viktel Aria and the northernmost reaches of the Silk Road. It is a safe assumption that Venna was struck, Ar's Station, and other allied cities in the traditional demesne of Ar.

Who knows what finally compelled the High Council of Ar to take action? Perhaps the men of Treve had even dared to practice chain luck upon the high bridges of Ar herself. Whatever the case, the aerial patrols and air defenses of Ar were no longer considered adequate to stem the rising tide of attacks. So a plan was drawn up to launch the entire tarn cavalry of Ar against Treve and wipe her from the map once and for all, to crush her Home Stone and put an end to that city.

Piecing Together the Puzzle: As popular as it is in the songs and poems, there is actually little known about the details of the conflict.

The battle’s setting made it impossible for it to be witnessed by anyone other than the participants, whose few and scattered accounts are often tainted with partiality and hyperbole. Actually, it is not easy to find warriors from Ar to step forward and speak of the event. Perhaps the majority of the survivors have since perished in other actions. Perhaps it is a battle they loathe to speak of. To our knowledge, no warrior of Treve has stepped forward to give an eyewitness account of the battle to historians of other cities.

The scarcity of eyewitnesses means a scarcity of written records. Ubars are not quick to authorize detailed records of humiliating defeats. In her history Ar has not suffered many defeats, but the specifics of this one is glaringly omitted from the annals of her military histories. It is a safe assumption that the libraries of Treve contain such records. Perhaps her warriors are required to study them as part of their training to this day. If that’s the case, however, the city hoards them, keeping them a guarded secret.

Thus, the best we can do in reconstructing the battle is build a framework of conjecture and hypothesis, based on the facts that we do have. The tactics of tarn warfare have changed little over the centuries, and this gives us our only advantage in deciphering the strategy used by both cities in their deadly duel over the Red Mountains.

The Battle Unfolds: It is not known if the Ubar of Ar was aware of the precise location of Treve or not. More likely he had come to know its approximate position in the mountains, and considered that sufficient to order a large scale strike against the city. Based on what we know of Ar’s size, there had to be at least 5,000, and perhaps as many as 10,000 sent on the grisly mission. At any rate, the men of Treve would be outnumbered by a factor of several to one. They would, however have two very important elements in their favor.

The decision of the Trevan military could have consisted of only one possible course of action: dispatch harriers to slow the flight of the advancing enemy cavalry and regroup the main body of their forces at Treve to repel. A decisive counter strike against the relatively undefended city of Ar, enmasse, might have forced the tarnsmen of Ar to divide her forces and wing home to protect the city, but Treve could not do both; their military strategy was based upon raiding, true, but such an attempt would have divided Treve's forces as well, and Treve was already outnumbered. They could not spare a single man for the attempt. To do so would be to risk the Home Stone. They would have to face Ar's forces on their own ground, where a uniform line of defense might be maintained. Only over Treve would her tarnsmen refuse to retreat, and fight unto the death if need be.

We can reasonably assume that this is what they did. The raiding parties nearest to the air cavalry of Ar's line of approach would be reinforced with the best airborne raiders closest enough to lend a hand, and a series of punitive strikes would be launched to slow the encroaching enemy tarnsmen.

Whatever the tactics used, the engagement constituted something never before seen on the face of the planet. The forces of Trev battle, did gain one important objective. Sa sleen and the ferocity of a cornered larl. They had to. Their Home Stone was at stake. In the end, the tarn cavalry of Ar, beleaguered and disorientated, was turned back from the Voltai, unable to locate, much less assault their would be target. Treve had drawn a line in the sky, and had held the line.

Winners and Losers Obviously, the greatest winner in the engagement was Treve. Most importantly she has saved her own existence. Also, she had turned back the most feared of all cities, glorious Ar. This fact in itself could only embellish her reputation, making her name even more feared by those that she preyed upon- not an unimportant thing for a city of raiders. Too, the victory would enhance the valor of her tarnsmen for generations to come. The victory secured her place as the master of the northern Voltai.

Ar, for her part, though she lost the battle, did gain one important objective. She managed to check, at least to a degree, the campaigns of Treve. It would be more than a century before the tarnsmen of Treve would attempt to despoil the fields of Ar. In fact, they would at least pause before directly attacking the assets of another high city. Ar had taught her enemy a powerful lesson, one that would not soon be forgotten.

The Thentis Mystique Only one city has been known to be left completely alone by the tarnsmen of Treve. That city is Thentis. Several reasons for this have been speculated: first, Thentis, being a mountain city little more in the way of agricultural resources than does Treve. She has considerable silver deposits, but these might be too well guarded and too cumbersome to acquire and escape with on a raid; second, the tarnsmen of Thentis are, man for man, the most respected on Gor. One could not blame even those of Treve for thinking of declining to invade her airspace, whether it be out of fear or mutual respect. Thirdly, many believe that a sort of kindred spirit exists between the men of Treve and the men of Thentis, which springs from both of them being mountain cities. One can only wonder how great and how fierce a battle between their tarn cavalries would be, if one ever took place.

From The Journals of _Marcus of Ar_
On the Tactics of Treve

10,000 tarnsmen is too many to form a single wave of attackers. No strategist worth his salt would attempt to do so. Now, this is simply conjecture on my part, but I assume that the attacking tarnsmen of Ar would be divided into several flights, each flight consisting of several hundred three-man "flying Vs", all flying and supporting one another at close range. Missle men (armed with crossbow and javelin)would be placed at strategic points throughout each flight, where they could use their missles to the utmost effect while still relying upon the relative security of the group formation. For the initial air-to-air assault, the misslemen would have been concentrated on the outside flanks of each flight, to repel any dive attacks from the Trevans and to possibly suppress any ground missle fire which might be encountered.

So... the men of Ar, having already been struck at by the outlying raiders and aerial skirmishers sent by Treve to delay them, would have appeared in the skies in the vicinity of Treve.

The goal of the Trevans would have been simple: stop the forces of Ar from finding the city itself. That city's precise location is the best kept secret on Gor. It is easier to find Port Kar, than to find Treve. If the cavalry of Ar can effectively survey the mountains in the area surrounding Treve, they can effectively locate that city and effectively destroy it. The Home Stone must be protected at all cost.

Therefore, the Trevans do what they are best at: they harry the incoming tarnsmen like a stream of falling comets, crashing downward at the rows of enemy tarnsmen. Wave after wave of Trevans plummet from the clouds and smash into the formations of the tarnsmen of Ar, slaying countless tarnsmen of Ar before they are peppered with enemy missle and their tarns fall from the sky to the stony ground far below. The ranks of Ar falter and fall apart, their formations broken, and they fall back to regroup, as another flight of perfectly ordered and neatly arranged tarnsmen of Ar fall in to take their place, circling the skies in search of the enemy city…

The result is chaos. The cavalry of Ar must break formation and deal with the Trevans. Perhaps the Trevans have inflicted enough damage to the tarnsmen of Ar to require a counter attack; or perhaps enough Trevans have been slain to suggest that it is time to mop them up. In any event, I surmise that eventually the formations of Ar loosened up and split into their respective squadrons, each squadron seeking combat with a similar, smaller squadron of Trevans. Then the battle begins in earnest, as the Trevans and the cavalry of Ar meet face to face and man to man, whirling through the skies in what could only be described as a giant free for all. Treve would have suffered losses... so would the men of Ar. Individuals and squadrons would have fought for cohesiveness and structure in the spinning three dimensional theater of engagement which is the staple of air combat.

On The Outcome

Treve managed, by using up most of her tarn power, to give Ar a bloody nose and save their city. Ar managed, by sending thousands of her native sons against the superbly skilled Trevan tarnsmen, to prove the effectiveness of its tactics, which rely largely upon discipline and massed troop maneuvers, to smash apart any guerilla force. That doctrine would remain unchallenged until the horrible mismanagement of that doctrine which resulted in the fiasco which occurred in the Vosk Delta one hundred and twenty years later.

Neither city has forgotten the lessons it learned in the skies above Treve. Treve learned that no guerilla force is capable of winning a decisive victory against a well-trained, well led professional military machine, without huge losses and the suicidal use of its troops to whittle down the enemy. Ar learned that massed formation tactics, while they can be effective, are only decisive if the formation can be maintained long enough to achieve the intended objective. Without support and under ceaseless guerilla sniping, any massed formation can be reduced to the point where the formation can no longer be effectively maintained.